Locum Tenens Physicians in California: Employee or Independent Contractor?

This article is for educational purposes only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

California employment lawyers continue to confront one deceptively simple question: when a physician accepts temporary work through a staffing agency, is the agency an employer or merely a broker of professional services? The answer turns on layered statutory schemes, a forty-year-old Supreme Court precedent, and a handful of policy choices that often cut in opposite directions on a case-by-case basis. The discussion below is designed for practitioners who need an integrated view of the problem before a mediation session, a demurrer hearing, or a misclassification audit. It is not legal advice.

Start with the Statutes: To be or not to be an employee

Locum tenens presumption of independent‑contractor status.
Business and Professions Code § 2418 says a locum tenens agency “shall not be deemed to be an employer,” and subdivision (e) creates a rebuttable presumption that the relationship between the agency’s hospital client and the physician is one of independent contractor.

Parallel presumption in the Unemployment Insurance Code.
§ 656 likewise presumes that professional services, including those of a physician, are rendered as an independent contractor, but leaves room for rebuttal.

Corporate‑practice‑of‑medicine Prohibition.
California’s Corporate Practice of Medicine (CPOM) rule, based on Business & Professions Code § 2400, states that corporations don’t have professional rights and forbid non-physician entities from practicing medicine.

Staffing and recruiting firms often cite this rule to show that, as a matter of public policy, they cannot lawfully employ doctors.

Pushed by a steady rise in misclassification suits and emerging legal challenges about the gig economy, the legislature created California Assembly Bill 5 (AB 5) and codified it as Labor Code § 2775. AB5 came on the heels of the Court’s opinion in the Dynamex case (Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court of Los Angeles, 4 Cal.5th 903 (2018).  In the Dynamex case, the California Supreme Court held that the three-pronged “ABC Test” must be used to determine worker classification in wage-order claims (e.g., minimum wages and other minimum worker benefits issued by California’s Industrial Welfare Commission).

Under the ABC Test, a worker is presumed to be an employee, rather than an independent contractor, unless the hiring entity can demonstrate all of the following conditions are met: (A) The worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact; B) The worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and C) The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as that involved in the work performed.

AB5 Exemptions

Doctors and certain medical professionals, and dozens of worker classifications of employment were exempted from AB5. If AB5 exemptions applied, instead of the ABC Test, the classification for such workers would be determined by the multi-factor test set forth in S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations, 48 Cal.3d 341 (1989). No one factor of the multi-factor test is dispositive.

AB 5 also underwent significant revision via Assembly Bill 2257. The legislature codified those changes in California Labor Code § 2778, amending certain sections of AB5, clarifying, and adding new statutory exemptions from the ABC Test. Under § 2778, doctors are and will continue to be exempt.

How the Competing Narratives Line Up

Physician‑plaintiff themes

  • The agency dictates mandatory shift start and end times, imposes electronic medical‑record protocols, and subjects the doctor to quality‑assurance audits.
  • Economic dependence. A single income stream, malpractice coverage arranged by the agency, and exclusivity clauses show classic employee dependence.
  • Staffing doctors is the agency’s core business, so doctors are integral to that enterprise.

Agency‑defendant themes

  • Statutory presumptions. Business & Professions Code §§ 2418 and 656 place the burden on the doctor to show real control inconsistent with an independent‑contractor relationship.
  • Professional autonomy. The physician exercises unfettered clinical judgment and can decline any proposed assignment.
  • Separate enterprise. Many physicians maintain their own professional corporations and insurance, signaling a distinct business.
  • Corporate‑practice rule.2400 confirms that a non‑physician owned agency cannot employ the doctor even if it wanted to.

Evidence to Request or Produce

  • Signed engagement agreements, including any termination or exclusivity clauses.
  • Credentialing emails that show who actually sets the schedule.
  • Rate sheets and invoices tracing who negotiated the compensation.
  • Badge‑swipe or time‑keeping data used for billing.
  • Copies of malpractice and workers’ compensation policies.
  • Tax forms (W‑2 versus 1099).
  • Hospital medical‑staff bylaws addressing clinical privileges.

Each item can support or undermine multiple Borello factors and the statutory presumptions.

Wage and Hour Exposure if Misclassification Is Proven

  • Overtime. A physician is exempt only if paid a minimum hourly rate of $103.75 per hour in 2025.
  • Meal and rest premiums. Wage Order 5 can generate one hour of pay per missed break.
  • Expense reimbursement. Labor Code § 2802 covers mileage, continuing‑education costs, DEA fees, and tail coverage.
  • Waiting time penalties. Thirty days of pay under Labor Code § 203 if final wages are not paid timely.
  • PAGA penalties. Civil penalties accrue per pay period and can leverage settlement pressure.

The damages profile is often smaller than in hourly‑worker cases because many physicians clear the overtime threshold, but exposure is still significant.

Strategic Takeaways for Both Sides

For the physician.

  • Challenge the statutory presumptions with concrete evidence of agency control, especially over rates and scheduling.
  • Emphasize exclusivity and economic dependence.
  • Anticipate the agency’s corporate‑practice defense and be ready to distinguish it when the agency’s owners are physicians.

For the staffing agency.

  • Audit contracts to ensure physicians truly set or approve their own rates, as required by § 2418.
  • Avoid mandating training or uniform clinical protocols that erode professional autonomy.
  • Document each physician’s separate entity, malpractice policy, and right to reject shifts.
  • Keep hourly pay above the overtime exemption level as a backstop.

For the mediator or judge.

  • The dual statutory presumptions give the defense an initial edge, but they are rebuttable.
  • Borello remains a fact‑intensive inquiry; summary judgment is rare unless the record is one‑sided.
  • Joint‑employment by the hospital is a live issue even if the agency prevails.

Recent Developments Worth Noting

  • The Ninth Circuit’s 2024 and 2025 decisions (some unpublished) upholding the overall constitutionality of AB 5 reaffirms that the ABC test remains the default for non‑exempt occupations, leaving the physician carve‑out intact.
  • The Department of Industrial Relations continues to update the exempt pay rate annually, a detail that can convert a theoretical exemption into real liability if overlooked.

Closing Thoughts

Locum tenens arrangements sit at the confluence of professional autonomy, hospital staffing pressures, and aggressive statutory worker protections. California gives the staffing agency a head start through the locum tenens and unemployment insurance presumptions, but that lead evaporates quickly if daily control and economic realities look like classic employment. Practitioners on both sides should build the factual record early, focus discovery on the most contested Borello factors, and keep the corporate‑practice rule firmly in view. Doing so positions the parties for informed risk assessment, efficient negotiation, and fewer surprises in court.

Not legal advice; for professional discussion only.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top